Skip to main content

Business > News

Thu, 06 Nov 2008 Apple faces lawsuit over defective PowerBooks

Apple faces another lawsuit, this time over flaws in the PowerBook G4

Gregg Keizer Computerworld

  • Email to a friend
  • Print this article
  • Bookmark this page
  • RSS feed

A New York man has sued Apple in federal court over flaws in the PowerBook G4 and has asked the judge to grant the case class-action status.

In a lawsuit filed last week in federal court in San Jose, Calif.,, Giorgio Gomelsky accused Apple of refusing to repair his PowerBook G4 notebook, which he said has a defective memory slot that has prevented him from adding more memory to speed up the system.

Question of the day!

Mark Hattersley
Editor in Chief

Do you share your creations online?

Question of the day!

Do you share your creations online?

% of Macworld readers agree with you

Yes
TBC
No
TBC

What do you create and how do you share it?

124 characters remaining

Follow the conversation at @TabletChat

paintings & illustrations, mostly, which i upload to flickr.RT @fragmentedm

I draw manga/anime characters. I also do graphic design and photography.RT @spialelo

Yes. I usually put them up on my #deviantart account for feedback on how to improve.RT @spialelo

Apple’s refusal, Gomelsky charged, was particularly galling because the company had previously acknowledged problems with PowerBook G4 memory slots and had set up a free-of-charge repair program for a limited number of systems.

In 2006, Apple debuted what it called the “PowerBook G4 Memory Slot Repair Extension Program,” which identified PowerBooks manufactured between January and April 2005 that might have defective memory slots. Apple documented the program in an online document and said that symptoms could include the notebook not booting or not recognizing memory in one slot. “System performance may be degraded because the memory in only one slot is not recognized,” said Apple, which added that the problems may be intermittent.

Apple repaired without charge those PowerBook G4 laptops with such symptoms that fell within a serial number range. The program, however, ended July 24, 2008.

Gomelsky’s lawsuit said that he had bought a PowerBook G4 in April 2004, and two years later, added another 1GB of memory to his laptop. “Computer functioning did not improve, and was in fact worse than when Plaintiff’s computer had less memory installed,” the suit said. “It was at this time that Plaintiff realized that his PowerBook’s upper memory slot was defective.”

Although Gomelsky contacted Apple and asked that his PowerBook be fixed, the company turned him down because the machine’s serial number did not fall within the designated range. According to his lawsuit, Gomelsky also joined an online petition signed by nearly 4,500 PowerBook owners in similar circumstances, and filed a complaint with the California attorney general.

Repairing the PowerBook himself was out of the question, Gomelsky said. “The expense in repairing the memory slot—upwards of $500—would constitute almost half of the original purchase price of the computer,” the suit said.

Gomelsky’s lawsuit, which seeks class-action status, asks for reimbursement for repairs of defective memory slots, as well as other compensatory damages.

Email A Friend

Email this article to a friend or colleague:



PLEASE NOTE: Your name is used only to let the recipient know who sent the story, and in case of transmission error. Both your name and the recipient's name and address will not be used for any other purpose.

<<prev article | back to news index | next article>>

Comments received


James said on Thu, 06 Nov 2008

I hope it works for him, I've suffered from this and my computer now runs slower using a single 1Gb chip in the working slot than when I had the two pre-installed 256mb chips (which seemed to work in both slots). Sadly I'd chucked the old RAM by the time I realised what was going on!

alessandro sisto said on Thu, 06 Nov 2008

I still have the same problem but I didn't use the extension cause my macbook serial was out from the ones that apple chose

Joe said on Thu, 13 Nov 2008

We hope Apple can extend this program to other powerbook owners.My situation's similar to Gomelsky.Otherwise we are headed for ifixit(repair tutorial manual) and ebay(second hand logic board.)

Disclaimer
Opinions expressed here are those of the writers and do not reflect those of Macworld. Macworld accepts no responsibility legal or otherwise for their accuracy of content.
Click here to read the house rules.

Click here for the latest reader comments

Latest News


More news...