e were fascinated to compare Microsoft and Apple set-top philosophies. Based on looks, the Xbox 360 loses out immediately; it’s like a desktop PC from the 1990s, and yes, appearances matter if it’s going to live in your living room.

The external mains power brick is also pretty appalling – it’s huge. A composite AV cable is included, though component and HD versions are available separately. There’s no built-in WiFi, which is disappointing, so we hooked up the ethernet to our BT WiFi hub.

After logging in to Xbox Live and obtaining the necessary software updates, we installed Nullriver's Connect360 on our MacBook Pro ($20), to index OS X’s iTunes and iPhoto libraries (Windows users won’t need any extra software thanks to the Windows Media Center).

As with all of these boxes apart from the Apple TV, protected iTunes files couldn’t be played, but AAC music and videos in iTunes play happily as do DVDs and CDs. Microsoft also has a comprehensive movie download service and both standard and HD movies can be rented.

One major drawback of the Xbox 360 is the fan, which is considerably louder than on any other device we tried and a major distraction.

Finally, we should mention that the Xbox 360 has a poor track record for reliability, and that – despite the big fan – overheating is common with the power switch turning red and the console refusing to function. Microsoft does, however, offer a three-year guarantee for this specific problem.

Considering the movie rental service, DVD/CD playback, and of course the core gaming activities, the Xbox is probably the best one-box solution, though Mac users will find it less satisfying. Shame about the fan, but it’s good value so crank up your speakers and drown it out.

This product is part of our iTunes compatible set-top boxes reviewed group product review. Other products in this group are:

 

Apple TV 2.2

  • Star rating: 3

Apple's TV project integrates into your home brilliantly, but is quite pricey

 

Nintendo Wii

  • Star rating: 2

Nintendo's Wii console is great for games, but not for iTunes

 

PlayStation 3

  • Editors ChoiceStar rating: 5

The PlayStation 3 is the finest all-in media box for your lounge


Reevoo Price Comparison For Apple TV 2.2

Reevoo Reviews For Apple TV 2.2

Reevoo Price Comparison For Nintendo Wii

Price comparison powered by Reevoo

£5
£15
£28
£30
£33
£35
£35

Reevoo Reviews For Nintendo Wii

Reevoo Price Comparison For PlayStation 3

Reevoo Reviews For PlayStation 3

Reevoo Price Comparison For Xbox 360

Price comparison powered by Reevoo

£20
£30
£40
£47

Reevoo Reviews For Xbox 360

<<back to iTunes compatible set-top boxes reviewed review