For almost two years now, I’ve started nearly every morning by reaching for my iPad. Before I even get out of bed, I check email, catch up on Twitter, read some comics, and surf the web. However, when it’s time for work, I put down the iPad and get out my Mac.

But as the iPad’s hardware and software have developed since its launch in 2010, and especially since the recent release of iOS 5, I’ve ben wondering whether that handoff is really necessary. Can the iPad replace a Mac for work? Or, more accurately, what kinds of work can it do now? What kinds of sacrifices are still required?

Can you actually get things done with it? I volunteered to be the guinea pig for a little experiment.

For three days, I vowed to go Mac-less, using my iPad instead of my laptop for everything. Here’s how it went.

Day One

The Physical Challenge

For 20 years, I’ve been using a Mac; for the last five, I’ve used one almost daily to write. So that first morning, when I shambled into my home office and sat down at the desk, it struck me just how different working with an iPad would be.

On a normal day, my job involves some combination of reading and writing email; using web-based tools to manage, develop, write, and edit stories; communicating with my colleagues via instant message and an online chat room; and reading RSS feeds and Twitter. Of course, I also spend a lot of time browsing the web and listening to music, and take care of bits of personal business, such as emailing and chatting with friends and family, or paying bills.

I already do a lot of these things interchangeably on my Mac and my iPad. In fact, I find browsing my RSS feeds in Reeder on my iPad more pleasant than reading them on the Mac. Likewise, reading Twitter using Twitterrific feels more natural on the iPad than it does on my Mac. But using the iPad as my sole work machine would require some adjustments.

Setting up

My initial instinct was to set up the iPad just like my Mac. So, using a £19.95 Stump stand (amazon.co.uk), I propped up the tablet on my desk, its little 10in display dwarfed by the 27in Cinema Display next to it.

I then paired my Apple Wireless Keyboard to the iPad via Bluetooth. While I’ve become pretty adroit at typing on the iPad, I’m not nearly as fast on the touchscreen keyboard as I am on a real one. After years of touch typing (thanks, Mavis Beacon), it’s weird to have to repeatedly glance at my fingers to make sure they’re on the iPad’s home row.

I started out on the first day by responding to a few emails and checking in with colleagues. Because I work at home, much of my interaction with coworkers is conducted via instant messaging and an online
chat room. The first was no problem: I’ve used BeejiveIM (£6.99; itun.es/iS6827) for a long time, and it works great.

The online chat room was trickier. While I could access the service I use (Campfire; campfirenow.com) through a web browser, the web interface lacks some of the features of the Mac app I use. I tested a couple of iPad clients: No Spoon Software’s £2.99 Sparks for iPad (itun.es/iS68pf) and David Dollar’s 69p Pyre (itun.es/iS68pq). While Sparks has a better interface, I prefer Pyre for a couple of minor features, including the ability to press the Return key on my Bluetooth keyboard to send a message. Neither of them, however, supports push notifications (more on that later).

Office communication tools such as instant messaging (Beejive IM, pictured here) and an online chat room (Campfire) work fine on the iPad

My morning catch-up done, it was time to check in on the iPad and iPhone User website (www.ipadiphoneuser.co.uk). To do that, I use two web-based apps - a content management system (CMS) and a story management tool. Both of them appeared intact in the iPad’s version of Safari. So it was time to get down to work and edit a story.

I immediately ran into glitches. For example, the CMS tool allows me to edit in either raw HTML or a wysiwyg view. The raw HTML view worked fine on the iPad, but the wysiwyg editor didn’t: I got just a blank white canvas. If you rely on web apps for your work, they may or may not work on an iPad.

Fortunately, I had a fallback plan: I copied the raw HTML and pasted it into a text editor, where it would be easier to work with. Now, there are loads of good text editors for the iPad – almost too many, really. The problem is that no single one has all of the features I want. I ended up using a combination of them, including Quang Anh Do’s £2.99 Writing Kit (itun.es/iS68Kd) and Yutaka Yagiura’s £2.49 Textforce (itun.es/iS68Kw). Writing Kit has a built-in web browser, among other compelling features, and Textforce was the only app I could find that would let me run a search and replace all command. Still, no iOS text editor came close to matching my weapon of choice on the Mac, BBEdit (£34.99; www.barebones.com).

I did find myself increasing the font size in both text editors. The text might have been big enough when I was holding the iPad at arm’s length, but it was too small when the iPad was propped on a desk. (I was thankful for the iPad’s pinch-to-zoom feature.) While the iPad’s smaller screen size didn’t bother me too much, I found the angle of the display on the desk ungainly. I had to hunch over to see it clearly, which probably wasn’t great for my neck.

Despite those shortcomings, I managed to edit my first piece and copy it back into the CMS without a hitch. A pleasing result.

Awkward gestures

When it was finally time for the last challenge of my first day - writing an end-of-the-day wrap-up piece - I again turned to Writing Kit. With the Bluetooth keyboard, writing on the iPad felt a little different from doing so on my Mac. The one big down side was that I needed to switch back and forth between the document and a webpage when I wanted to copy a link or other piece of text.

There is no shortage of text editors for the iPad. But no single editor has all of the features you might want

Although iOS 5’s multitasking gestures (Settings > General) let you quickly switch between apps using four-finger swipes, I didn’t end up using them much. Because of the stand holding the iPad upright, performing gestures was awkward; I had to brace the iPad with my other hand to keep it steady. Instead,
I ended up double-clicking the iPad’s Home button, which was easy to do with one hand.

That made it somewhat slow and laborious to switch between apps when the iPad was in the stand. I found myself longing for the quick efficiency of the Mac’s 1-tab shortcut for switching applications.

When I was finished writing, I used Writing Kit’s export feature to send the text to my clipboard as HTML. I pasted the finished story into the web tool; with that, my day was done.