Wed, 06 Feb 2013 Microsoft Surface Pro (128GB) review: Microsoft's attempt to build a laptop-class Windows computer inside a tablet
Surface Pro is the world's best Windows tablet, but still can't close the deal
- Manufacturer: Microsoft
- Manufacturer: Microsoft
- Pros: Runs traditional Windows programs, Intel processor, Wacom-style pen input
- Cons: Expensive, heavy, screen feels too small, keyboard doesn't feel quite good enough
- Min specs: Windows 8 Pro; 275x173x13.5mm; 900g; VaporMg casing; Dark Titanium color; Volume and Power buttons; Storage: 64GB, 128GB; 10.6in ClearType Full HD Display; 1920x1080 pixels; 16:9 (widescreen); 10-point multi-touch; Pen Input ; 3rd Gen Intel Core i5 Processor with Intel HD Graphics 4000; 4GB RAM—Dual Channel Memory; Wi-Fi (802.11a/b/g/n); Bluetooth 4.0 Low Energy technology; 42 W-h battery; Two 720p HD LifeCams, front- and rear-facing with TruColor; Microphone, Stereo speakers; Full-size USB 3.0; microSDXC card slot; Headset jack; Mini DisplayPort; Cover port; Ambient light sensor; Accelerometer; Gyroscope; Compass; 48W power supply (including 5W USB for accessory charging); 1-year limited hardware warranty
- Price: £719 inc VAT for 64GB model; £799 for 128GB model
- Star rating:
Microsoft's Microsoft Surface Pro is the latest update to Microsoft's iPad-esque tablet range. The key difference between Microsoft Surface and the Microsoft Surface Pro, is that it's packing an Intel processor instead of an Arm, the storage space ranges from 64GB to 128GB and - crucially - it is running Microsoft Windows 8 Pro rather than the stripped-down Microsoft Windows RT. And the key difference there is that Windows 8 is cabale of running full Windows programs as well as the apps.
So what we really have here is the first attempt to build a laptop-class Windows computer inside the modern multi-touch tablet format. As with the Microsoft Surface you can buy a Smart Cover-esque flap that also doubles as a keyboard and trackpad.
There's still no official word on how much the Surface Pro will cost in the UK, although it is definitely coming out over here. Our friends over at PC Advisor have this article quoting UK price estimates:
"With prices of $899 and $999, we think the sterling price for the Surface Pro in the UK could well be between £749 and £799 for the 64GB model. Microsoft will want the price jump to the 128GB model to be small enough to tempt buyers to spend a bit more. We predict another £100 placing the 128GB Surface Pro between £849 and £899."
And our friends over at PC World in the US have taken delivery of a Microsoft Surface Pro and have helped us with this review.
Propped up on its VaporMg kickstand, Surface Pro cuts a handsome profile.
What is the Microsoft Surface Pro?
Microsoft Surface RT was a broken promise. When it launched in October, it showed the world a vision of a revolutionary tablet-laptop hybrid, but it couldn’t close the deal. But now we have Surface with Windows 8 Pro, part two of Microsoft’s always fascinating, sometimes heartbreaking Surface saga. This is the hardware everyone has been waiting for. Surface RT was the warm-up act, the proof-of-concept, but the good money has always been on Surface Pro, the Surface sibling with PC-caliber specs and a fully functioning desktop.
The good news: Surface Pro is a marked improvement over Surface RT. It has a vastly better display and Ultrabook-caliber components. And thanks to Windows 8 Pro, it can run all the legacy desktop applications that we need for serious productivity. Surface Pro comes much closer than Microsoft’s ARM-based RT offering to fulfilling that elusive promise of uniting a tablet and a PC in a single, uncompromised package.
The bad news: Surface Pro doesn’t run away with the Windows 8 hybrid crown. And based on your needs, it might not be the best Windows 8 portable you can buy in the neighborhood of $1000. This is a problem because Surface Pro needs to stand out as a kick-ass reference design, and not be just another interesting-but-imperfect hardware option for anyone taking the Windows 8 plunge.
There's no mistaking that Surface Pro is thicker than its ARM-based sibling.
Surface Pro: Thicker chassis, better display
Relative to Surface RT and the latest 9.7-inch iPad, Surface Pro is thick, chunky, and heavy with palpable mass. Both the new iPad and Surface RT weigh 1.5 pounds and are 9.4mm thick, while Surface Pro weighs 2 pounds and measures 13.5mm thick. The tablet’s heft and girth aren’t deal-breakers, but I’m disappointed that the engineers in Redmond weren’t able to dazzle the world with a truly svelte design. A technological breakthrough along those lines would have made headlines and buoyed the flagging Surface brand.
Still, if you want a handheld tablet and an Ultrabook-caliber PC in the very same molded magnesium case, you’ll have to accept some compromises (at least until technology catches up to ergonomics).
Releasing Surface Pro with a Retina-caliber display would have given Microsoft an impressive talking point, but that didn't happen. Nonetheless, the new tablet’s 1920-by-1080-pixel, 10.6-inch screen delivers 208 pixels per inch for a level of visual clarity that’s practically indistinguishable from that of the latest iPads (whose pixel pitch is 264 ppi). In comparing Surface Pro to my third-generation iPad, I really had to search for visible pixels and differences in display quality, and any deficits exhibited by Surface Pro melted away when the tablet was farther away from my face, and propped on a desk. The Surface Pro display is a serious upgrade over Surface RT's 1366-by-768-pixel, 148-ppi screen.
Basic visual quality aside, the Surface family’s 10.6-inch screens don’t offer enough real estate for complex desktop productivity tasks like image editing. Nor can you comfortably run multiple open chat windows on such a puny display. For these reasons, it’s nice that the Pro comes with a Mini DisplayPort, which can drive not only HDMI connections (a trick Surface RT also offers via its “HD video out” port) but any device with a VGA input. The upshot is that you can take your Surface Pro on the road, and connect it to any antiquated monitor or projector you may encounter—a boon if you need to present a PowerPoint deck to a bunch of insurance underwriters in Tulsa.
The Surface Pro didn’t have any trouble driving a 24-inch Dell monitor at a resolution of 1920 by 1080, mirroring the two screens at the same resolution. And when I added Microsoft’s Wedge Touch Mouse to the mix, the setup handily delivered a desktop experience - save for the lack of a comfortable keyboard, which I discuss below.
Because Surface Pro is a PC-class device running an Ultrabook-caliber Core i5 processor, it faces all the heat dissipation issues that confront a true laptop. As a result, unlike Surface RT with its sealed exterior, Surface Pro has an open grille that runs halfway around the perimeter of the chassis. Inside the tablet, two nearly silent fans dissipate heat through this venting.
During my testing, Surface Pro never felt unusually hot. In fact, I’ve felt more heat coming from the back of my third-generation iPad at times. As for fan noise, I could hear the blowers only when I put the tablet against the side of my head. It’s like raising a shell to your ear in order to “hear the sound of the sea” - inoffensive and ultimately inconsequential.
Microsoft Surface Pro: Ultrabook-caliber specs and performance
When you dig into Surface Pro’s specs and benchmark results, you see not a tablet, but a full-fledged Windows 8 hybrid. Surface Pro includes a 1.7GHz Core i5 CPU, 4GB of RAM, and an integrated GPU care of Intel’s HD Graphics 4000. And like all of those other new Windows 8 machines (except the ThinkPad Twist), the $1000 Surface Pro comes with a 128GB SSD (a $900, 64GB version of Surface Pro is also available, but we didn't get one in for review).
Surface Pro is an able Photoshop performer; and thanks to the Wedge mouse the entire setup can approximate a desktop experience.
With its familiar selection of internal components, Surface Pro delivered unsurprising benchmark results. In the PCMark 7 productivity suite, Microsoft’s tablet trailed the Acer W700 but out-performed all of its Core i5 stablemates mentioned above. Surface Pro also finished second in our Photoshop CS6 image editing test, outpacing all of its direct competitors except the Dell XPS Duo 12.
I spent a fair amount of time using Surface Pro for Photoshop work, and the machine delivered all the raw processing performance I needed for website production. Files opened lickety-split, and resizes, rotations, and filter conversions zipped along at a rapid clip - including work on a 70MB TIFF file. The Photoshop performance is remarkable when you consider that Surface Pro is only half a pound heavier and 4mm thicker than the latest iPad.
The Pro’s integrated graphics will break your heart if you try to play 3D games at the machine’s native resolution of 1920 by 1280. In our Civilization V and Dirt Showdown gaming tests, frame rates were unplayably poor, with numbers in the mid-teens at best. You shouldn’t expect much better from any device running a Core i5 processor and integrated graphics. We did, however, see a playable 34 frames per second in Dirt Showdown after reducing in-game resolution to 1366 by 768 and setting visual quality to low.
Unfortunately, Surface Pro doesn’t boast much interior space compared to larger Windows 8 tablets and hybrids. This constraint limits the physical dimensions of anything stuffed inside it, which probably explains why Microsoft specced Surface Pro with just a 42-watt-hour battery. This component represents a big leap forward from the 31-watt-hour battery deployed inside Surface RT, but other Core i5 hybrids run beefier cells. Acer's W700 and Lenovo's Yoga 13, for example, are bigger devices that pack 54-watt-hour batteries.
The upshot is that Surface Pro’s battery endurance is mediocre. In our video rundown test, the Pro lasted only 5 hours, 8 minutes, whereas the W700 gave up the ghost in 6 hours, 7 minutes, and the Yoga 13 pooped out in 5 hours, 37 minutes. (Also noteworthy: Those two competing hybrids have bigger screens, which puts heavier demands on their batteries.) Of course, many pure Ultrabooks post similar battery life numbers, but Surface Pro looks like a power glutton compared to ARM-based tablets like Surface RT and the iPad, which can run for more than 9 hours before finally collapsing in defeat.
The 64GB version provides only 23GB of open storage - less than 36 percent of the machine’s marketed capacity. The operating system, preinstalled apps, and a recovery partition consume the remaining gigabytes. The 128GB Surface Pro, meanwhile, offers 83GB of usable storage capacity, good for 65 percent of the machine’s marketed capacity. These are disturbing figures, given that Surface RT grants 50 percent of its marketed capacity in the 32GB version, and 70 percent in the 64GB version. The 128GB iPad, meanwhile, makes more than 96 percent of its marketed spec available.
The annoying dearth of storage space reinforces the idea that Surface Pro can’t be your only PC. Rather, it becomes the machine you throw in your carry-on bag when you need legitimate PC power, but not all your applications and documents. Instead, you grab what you need from the cloud (hello, SkyDrive and Office 365), and then make do with the limited storage capacity that Microsoft provides.
You can free up some SSD space by copying your recovery partition to a USB key (here you’ll be glad that Surface Pro supports USB 3.0), and then deleting the partition from your machine. There’s also a MicroSDXC card slot in case you want to add onboard flash memory.
The device's heat vent runs along the entire upper half of the chassis and disrupts the clean lines that we saw in the original Surface offering.