Fri, 09 Nov 2007 Apple fails in attempt to end Burst.com lawsuit

Apple met just partial success in persuading court to declare Burst.com's iPod patents invalid

Jonny Evans

Apple last night partially failed in its bid to have Burst.com's iPod-focused patent infringement lawsuit thrown out of court.

Burst.com claims that some of its patents for receiving, storing and transmitting audio and video files are at the heart of the iPod.

The company first approached Apple to try to arrange a license for its claimed patents in late 2004. These attempts failed and the company later launched litigation against Apple in April 2006.

Apple has argued that the patents do not rightfully belong to Burst, or that the patents are invalid. Last year Burst settled litigation with Microsoft, which took a licence and paid Burst a $60m lump sum.

Apple took that argument to the courts yesterday, seeking a ruling to invalidate parts of four of Burst's patents. US District Judge Marilyn Patel did invalidate some elements of Burst.com's patents, but upheld others, meaning the case must now move on to an out-of-court settlement, appeal or trial.

In a statement on the Burst.com website, the company says: "Judge Marilyn Hall Patel of The United States District Court, Northern California, today issued an order that invalidated as obvious or anticipated 14 claims in the patents in suit between Apple Computer and Burst.com,. The order leaves 22 claims remaining, claims that the court did not find as invalid or anticipated. These remaining 22 claims include some significant audio and video claims that reach key Apple products including the Mac. Burst looks forward to trying its case in court against Apple early next year."

Apple does not comment on ongoing litigation.

RSS
Digg

Email A Friend

Email this article to a friend or colleague:

PLEASE NOTE: Your name is used only to let the recipient know who sent the story, and in case of transmission error. Both your name and the recipient's name and address will not be used for any other purpose.

Permalink This Article

This articles permalink is:
http://www.macworld.co.uk/ipod-itunes/news/index.cfm?newsid=19638

Click here for the latest reader comments

Latest News

More news...

Macworld Mobile

MACWORLD
FOR MOBILE

Related News

More iPod/iPhone news...

Mac Broadband?

Search news

Search Google

Newsletter signup

It's easy and free to get the latest news headlines, reviews and opinions straight to your email inbox. Sign up NOW to make sure you receive the latest Mac news, reviews and tutorials on your favourite topics.

Out now:
iPad & iPhone User

Find out what's in this month's Macworld here or buy now.

Macworld reader poll

Which type of Mac do you own? (Your primary Mac if you have more than one):

View poll results

Have your say in the
Macworld forums!

Register now

Stay on top of the latest, breaking Mac news and chat with other Mac professionals and enthusiasts about the issues that matter to you. Register with Macworld today to join our forums and receive our twice-weekly email newsletter, Macworld Mainline.

RSS

Have the latest content delivered to your desktop via RSS. Use the links below to get access to a specific blog, news, or reviews feed.

Subscribe to our feeds here

Latest PC industry news

MACWORLD MARKETPLACE

	Computer & Laptop At Ciao you can read consumer reviews on a large number of Apple products like iPods, iPhones, Apple laptops and Apple computers. Compare prices of your favourite Apple products today.
	Access your Mac from anywhere, anytime. With LogMeIn Pro² for Mac, you can remotely connect to your Mac from anywhere at any time from any computer with an Internet connection to access files, check mails, and even troubleshoot issues. It's simple, fast and comprehensive.
	Picture it Found Shutterstock is the largest subscription-based stock photo agency in the world. Every day we add thousands of photographs, illustrations, and vectors to our outstanding collection of premium, royalty-free images. 10% off your subscription with coupon code: DER410
	Mac1's walk-in repair shops Mac1's walk-in repair shops aim to fix any Mac, iPod or iPhone the same day - and you don't need an appointment. We can upgrade your Mac's hard drive or RAM and we also offer a cost effective data recovery service.
	Beat the Credit Crunch - Lease your Mac from Hardsoft Hardsoft are the only 'one stop' solution for the supply and finance of I.T. to businesses throughout the UK via our regional branch offices. We are uniquely both equipment Apple Approved Reseller and licensed Credit Brokers and have tailored a solution which includes a full 3 year warranty and an equipment upgrade every 18 month.
	Circus Ponies NoteBook - the easy way to get organized on the Mac NoteBook is the award-winning application that gets you organized. Store notes in electronic notebooks, add text, drag in files, "clip" web pages and other content. Annotate with diagrams, sketches, highlighting, keywords, even voice recordings. Find anything instantly with NoteBook’s patented Multidex^TM. Publish to the web, including MobileMe.
	Things – task management has never been this easy Organize your tasks in an elegant and intuitive way. Things combines powerful features with simplicity. Together with a beautiful user interface, Things makes task management both easy and fun.