Surgeon Simulator iPad game review

One key factor when evaluating ports of PC and console games on to iPad or iPhone is how well the controls have been adapted from keyboard, mouse and/or joypad to a touchscreen. But in this case that doesn't really apply, because the controls in Surgeon Simulator are deliberately terrible on both.

See also: iOS games academy: Tips to help you win at Surgeon Simulator for the iPad

Surgeon Simulator was a cult hit last year after being devised in a couple of days for Global Game Jam, and then being quickly polished up for commercial release. The whole thing is a single joke, essentially, but a rather good one: a life-or-death medical sim built around slapstick, ragdoll physics and cartoon graphics.

You're Nigel, a catastrophically clumsy surgeon, bumbling and fumbling your way through complex operations on a (frequently blood-spurting and bone-fragment-strewn) patient/victim named Bob. This clumsiness is imposed by the game's controls, which are so inaccurate that you spend half the game knocking medical instruments on the floor and losing things in the chest cavity. There is a vast and seemingly universal humour to this.

Surgeon Simulator iPad game review

Yet we do need to discuss the touchscreen controls a little. On the PC, both of the surgeon's hands were shown onscreen, and a fairly complex set of actions were possible using the mouse and keyboard: you could rotate a hand, control individual fingers, grasp, move up and down, all through specific (and totally unmanageable) inputs and key presses. Simply grabbing something was a challenge in itself.

The iPad version is simpler and - appropriately enough - more intuitive. You don’t see your hands (although you can still dual-wield); you just tap on things to grab them and swipe to move them around. You can tap with another finger to set a target, then make stabbing or sawing gestures to attack the spot. Sorry, 'operate' on the spot.

Toning down the sheer physical awkwardness was a risky move, of course; humour is notoriously delicate, and it would be a great shame to upset the balance. Happily, it's still nicely judged.

Best iPad and iPhone games | iPad Air review | iPad buying guide 2014

It's also very challenging, particularly when compared to the hand-holding, tutorial-heavy games common on mobile platforms. (If you do need a bit of help, try our tips for Surgeon Simulator.) Your first few cracks at the heart transplant that opens the campaign will end in disaster and panic, since you're given pretty much no advice; this is almost certainly deliberate, since failure in Surgeon Simulator is fun too, and you wouldn't want to miss out on the comedic value of misguidedly trying to crack open the ribcage with a hammer (instead of the correct tool - which we won't give away) before you learn the ropes.

Gradually you'll assemble the rudiments through tips on the (unhelpfully brief) loading screens and by delving into the PDA (a parody of the Apple Newton, pleasingly) on Nigel's desk. This explains the steps involved in every operation.

Surgeon Simulator iPad game review

Surgeon Simulator iPad game review

Surgeon Simulator iPad game review

Through sheer ignorance we found that the game's scant four levels (which are repeated a second time around in a more challenging 'corridor' environment, in which your trays of tools roll past only occasionally) lasted us a decent while. There are heart and kidney transplants, as will be familiar to players to the earlier game, but deeply unpleasant dental and eye surgeries have been added this time around. Keith Stuart of the Guardian superbly describes the latter as "like Un Chien Andalou only funnier".

And replayability is good, even after you've mastered these eight challenges. You'll want to experiment with all the tools and objects on the various operating tables - of which there is a good selection - and don't discount the simple pleasure of showing off. It's fun to horrify and amuse colleagues and friends with a quick demo, but there's also a multiplayer mode (where you race to complete a surgery before your rival) and a brilliant Recorder mode, expressly designed for the YouTubers who gave the game its early fame.

Here's our effort at an in-game video for Macworld's YouTube channel, which we must warn you contains horrifying eye trauma:

If you like Surgeon Simulator, you may also like:

Well, there's nothing quite like Surgeon Simulator. But we've got two suggestions which play totally differently but share its goriness, cruelty and sense of humour: the puzzle platformers Stealth Inc and Limbo.

OUR VERDICT

Terrible controls, basic graphics, limited number of levels, all in very bad taste. In other words it’s brilliant. Surgeon Simulator is a very good joke that doesn't outstay its welcome, and a pretty fun game in its own right.

Find the best price