Apple Music vs Google Play

Apple Music has finally arrived and thanks to a free three-month trial everybody has the chance to discover Apple’s new music service for themselves. Both Apple Music and Google Play offer a free service, and you pay extra for unlimited streaming of audio tracks from an online music catalogue.

Apple Music vs Google Play: Price and free features

In many ways, a comparison between Apple Music and Google Play makes more sense than a comparison to another service like Spotify. Both offer a similar set of features.

Read more of our Apple Music articles:

How to set up Apple Music

Apple Music versus Spotify

How to use Apple Music in the UK

Top 12 Apple Music tips

iTunes 12.2 review

What you get with Apple Music

Apple Music running on an iPhone

Here is a list of free and paid-for member features that come with Apple Music:

  • Free: Listen on iOS and iTunes
  • Free: Connect
  • Free: Beats 1
  • Free: Apple Music radio stations
  • Free: iCloud Music library (25,000 tracks)
  • Member: Unlimited streaming
  • Member: Unlimited skipping
  • Member: Play and save Connect content
  • Member: Like Connect content or radio songs
  • Member: Enjoy unlimited listening from the Apple Music library
  • Member: Add Apple Music content to your library
  • Member: Save for offline listening
  • Member: Get expert music recommendations

What you get with Google Play

Google Play on an iPhone

Here is a list of free and paid-for member features that come with Google Play:

  • Free: Listen on Android, iOS, and the web
  • Free: iTunes music sync (50,000 tracks)
  • Member: 30 million songs
  • Member: Instant mix
  • Member: Recommendations.
  • Member: Download music to play when you're not connected
  • Member: YouTube audio
  • Member: Skip as many songs as you want
  • Member: Offline listening

What’s interesting is that both services offer different features for user’s not willing to pay the £10 monthly fee. With Apple, you still get Beats 1 and the Apple Music radio stations for free. However, Google offers its iTunes Music Sync service (similar to iTunes Match or iCloud Music) as part of the free service. If all you’re looking for is a cheap way to get the music you own into the cloud then Google Play has you covered. Google Play’s free service even allows you to upload twice as many tracks as Apple Music.

What music is available to members

Members get unlimited streaming with both services (that’s the principle reason for subscribing). We’re not wholly sure how many tracks are in the Apple Music service because artists can opt-in and out. We’ve noticed some gaps on Apple Music from notoriously protective artists like Prince and Kate Bush.

Google Play also offers YouTube audio playback along with its legitimate music collection. This broadens the range of audio available considerably, especially as YouTube is often the principle way many people listen to tracks. You also get a lot of live performances and rarities on YouTube. With Google Play, you get to listen to YouTube audio for free and in the background on your iPhone. It’s a pretty strong selling point.

Discovering new music: curation, radio and suggestions

What separates Apple Music from other streaming services isn’t so much the basic service (unlimited streaming of audio tracks) but what surrounds it. Apple has clearly gone to great effort to push new songs your way. There are five tabs at the bottom of the Apple Music tab and three of them introduce you to new tracks:

  • For You. When you start using Apple Music you tap on genres and bands you like. Then the For You section shows playlists, songs and albums based on the music you’ve chosen. It’s surprisingly effective.
  • New. This does what it says on the tin and provides New Music, Hot Tracks and Recent Releases. There is also a spotlight section, currently showing Spotlight on Glastonbury. Scrolling down reveals Apple Music Editors, Activities and Curators sections. Right at the bottom is The A-List of tracks for genres like pop, dance and alternative.
  • Radio. The big draw here is Beats 1, Apple’s new global 24-hour radio station. Headed up by the infectious Zane Lowe it’s offering an interesting mix of classic tracks and new music. It works like a classic radio station but broadcasting around the world. Lowe says the only genre is “great” and so far we’ve loved what we’ve heard. Below Beats 1 are Featured Stations which work more like mix selections. You can skip the tracks in Featured Stations, but Beats 1 is broadcasting live so you tune in and listen to it.

Google Play doesn’t really have much to hold up to Apple here. It has some Playlists but nowhere near the depth or obsession that Apple has pushed into Apple Music. Google Play’s Instant Mixes and Apple’s New Station feature both serve up a selection of tracks based on the current track or artist.

Apple has pulled out all the stops in curation and we discovered more new music in two days of Apple Music than we did in months of using Google Play.

Read:

Apple Photos vs Google Photos comparison

Apple Maps vs Google Maps

5 things Apple could learn from Google

iOS versus Android

Social integration

Apple’s Connect service enables you to Follow musicians you like and get messages from them. Bands you download music from are automatically followed, so it’ll populate with your favourite bands over time. As these bands make announcements, you can then post on the band messages with other fans. It’s a bit early to call it, but we don’t think Connect is going to end up being very useful. So far we’ve got a few messages that Underworld are playing at the Hollywood Bowl and there’s a new Placebo album on the way. With no direct way for fans of a band to talk to each other (outside of on announcements of the band) it feels more like a marketing tool.

Where perhaps both Apple and Google fall down, at least compared to Spotify, is with social media integration. Neither service integrates with Facebook (other than to allow you to share links to your timeline). With Spotify you get deep integration with other people, can watch what your friends are listening to and the suggestions are based as much on what your friends are listening to, as the music you like. The community created playlists in Spotify are excellent too, often bringing together odd music collections (like this Mac N Cheese: fun songs about food, or Make It Stop: the worst songs ever). Apple Music has professionally curated playlists, and they’re great, but Spotify has the balmy stuff only the community can think of.

Google Play has neither.

OUR VERDICT

We think Apple Music has the edge on Google Play here. It’s direct integration with the Music app on the iPhone, amazing playlists and song suggestions give it the edge. Apple Music serves up an endless selection of new tracks for you to listen to, and Apple deserves a lot of credit for the effort it’s put into track curation. Google Play offers users a free way to stream tracks they own to an iPhone though, and if you don’t want to pay for membership it’s a good way to get music on the go.

Find the best price