If you want to edit a PDF, of fill in a PDF form, you may be thinking that your only option is to print it out, fill it in with a pen and then scan it and send it back. Luckily it’s not necessary to go to such lengths. There are free apps that make it easy to edit text in a PDF, including adding your signature, adding comments, and redacting information. You can also combine lots of PDFs, rotate pages, reduce the size of a PDF, and even convert PDFs to Word, Excel and other file tips. And it doesn’t have to cost a thing.

Here we look at a collection of PDF apps that, although the full version will cost you, the free trial version has a lot of the necessary functionality for a one-off PDF editing requirement.

Some of these apps do certain things better than others, so the best PDF editor for you will depend on what you need to do with it. For example, if you want a PDF editor that can use OCR (optical character recognition) to read the text on a page you have scanned, and allow you to edit it, we have an option that can allow you to do that. Alternatively, if you are looking for a PDF editor that’s simple to use and flexible enough to let you fill in a form without pulling out your hair, we have one below. We have even found a PDF tool that will let you import a PDF into Word (or Pages) and edit it there.

Some of these apps are free - including Preview, which is the PDF reader that is bundled with macOS. We have also looked at a number of apps that have free trial versions - which means that you may decide to pay the full price, or a monthly subscription - to use the app after the trial ends.

We have looked at the following features and abilities of the PDF Editors reviewed here:

Import: How faithful to the original PDF is the PDF editor? Does it maintain fonts and spacing? Can you open the PDF in Word, Excel etc?

Editing: Can you select text from the original PDF? Is the new text added in a separate text box?How easy is it to edit and delete content from the PDF? Can you move content around? Does the text you add maintain the style and formatting of the original PDF? Can you add hyperlinks or attach documents? Can you add images?

Collaboration: What markup tools are available? Can you highlight, underline, or strikethrough text? Can you use freehand drawing tools and an eraser. Can you add stamps? Can you track who reads and edits?

Signing: Can you add a signature? Is this signature scanned, imported, or typed? How many signatures can you save?

Saving: Can you resize the PDF? Can you stitch pages from multiple docs? Can you delete pages? Can you rotate pages?

Find & Replace: Can the PDF editor search the PDF? Can you find and replace words? Can you redact words?

OCR: Can the PDF editor read a scanned page - and can you edit that?

Watermark: Does it add a watermark? Can you add your own watermark?

We've tested the following trial and free versions of some of the best known PDF editors for Mac, read on to find out which one is best for you. 

You can also use Apple's own PDF editor Preview to edit PDFs on a Mac, read our tips for creating, saving, editing and sharing PDFs with Preview here.

PDFelement 6 Pro

PDFelement 6 Pro

PDFelement 6 Pro
Wondershare
Get it here
Free trial, $59.95 (approx £44)

The trial version of Wondershare’s PDFelement 6 did a good job of maintaining the text formatting and font of the PDF we opened in it.

We were able to easily add and delete text from the PDF, with text reflowing automatically. However, we found that moving things around the page was tricky and cutting and pasting text from one location to another was too fiddly. We were able to add an image, but because we couldn’t easily move things around the page it was difficult to make the document look good. That said, you should be able to adjust the size or images and graphs in the original PDF if you wish.

Adding a signature is possible. The options are to create the signature from typed text, from an image, with a camera, or by drawing with the mouse. We tried adding a signature we had scanned with the camera, dragging and dropping it onto the PDF was easy, but it looked terrible thanks to the grey background of the badly lit photograph. We tried creating a signature with the mouse and it looked a bit neater - although less like our signature. We were able to store more than one signature.

To access the highlighter, strike-through and underline tools you need to click on Select - it took a while before we discovered this. Here you will also find a pencil for free-hand drawing, an erase tool (which you will inevitably need for your scribbles), and a text box which will allow you to add comments if you are working with others on the document. To highlight or strike-through a word you click and swipe over the word. We found adding text notes via the text box was a little fiddly (and as we mentioned above, we ended up with lots of empty text boxes around the page). Luckily there are sticky notes which do a better job - you can find them under More… in the menu.

Searching the document is possible so although there is no redaction tool, you can just search for and remove sensitive information. There is an OCR (optical character recognition) function but it won’t work with the trial version.

There are a good range of document conversion tools. You can convert your PDF to Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Image, ePub, Text, Pages, HTML and RTF. You can delete pages from the PDF, combine individual pages to make a new PDF.

The trial version has a good selection of features. It does add a watermark, however.

The app itself wasn’t one of the best ones here though. We found that it wasn’t easy to use and the tools weren’t easily discoverable.

For more tips for using PDFelement Pro on a Mac read this.

PDFExpert for Mac

PDFExpert for Mac

PDFExpert for Mac
Readdle
Get it here
Free trial (7 days), £54.99

PDFExpert for Mac from Readdle also did a good job of maintaining the fonts, style and formatting of the original PDF.

There are two options for editing that you can find in the menu at the top of the page: Annotate and Edit. Under Annotate you will find the tool to easily add text to the PDF. You can choose the font and colour of the text here.

However, you will find the better editing tools under Edit. Here you have the option to edit text, add images, add hyperlinks, and redact sensitive information (you can choose to black out names, or you can search for a specific word and delete every occurrence of that.)

We were able to select text and move it around the page. But as we found with all the PDF editors here, it wasn’t possible to drag and drop text between pages (to get around this we were able to cut and paste though and still make a good looking document).

Back to the Annotate tab. Here you will find options to highlight, underline, or strike-through text, as well as a pan tool that means you can draw freehand in any colour, as well as change the line width and opacity. There’s also a crop tool here. In Annotate you can also add sticky notes and stamps (e.g. an Approval). You’ll see a column of existing annotations on the left so its easy to see what edits have been made and when. These annotations can be exported as HTML, text or markdown.

Adding a signature is also done via the Annotate tab. You can add more than one signature and these area added via the keyboard, trackpad, or an image. To add the signature to your PDF just drag and drop from the signature pane. You an also add a watermark yourself, perhaps your company logo, rather than having one added for you as is the case with some of the other trials looked at here.

Resizing a large PDF was easy thanks to a High/Low slider that indicated the size of the resulting file. There was also the option to merge files, combine multiple documents into one PDF, or individual pages from multiple documents.

We had one PDF that was scanned on our iPhone via the Notes app (we explain how to scan a document with an iPhone here). Obviously such a document will only be recognised by the PDF editor if the editor has OCR abilities that are unlocked in the trial. PDFExpert couldn’t do this so we weren’t able to edit the text in the scanned document, although we were able to add hyperlinks to sections of that document. Obviously we couldn’t search scanned document, or edit the text there.

We were able to search normal PDFs though, and we were able to search for a word and redact every occurrence of it either by blacking it out, or deleting it.

About the only thing we couldn’t do was export the PDF into Word or Excel, but the software was so intuitive that wasn’t really an issue here since the PDFExpert software is so intuitive and easy to use. Of course this is a seven day trial, so if you need the software for longer than that and don’t want to pay up then you would have to look elsewhere. But if you need something long term this would be a good buy.

Acrobat Reader DC

Acrobat Reader DC

Acrobat Reader DC
Adobe
Get it here
Free, full editing features require a subscription to Acrobat DC

While the Acrobat Reader app isn’t an editor as such, you can actually add text to a PDF using it, so we have included it in this roundup.

You can add text to a PDF via the Fill & Sign menu. Here you also have tools to tick and cross (that you might use if filling in a table for example). You can even run a spell check via Edit > Check Spelling.

There are also tools to strike-through, underline, draw and erase. Comments can be added, and you can see a sidebar which outlines comments, including replies from your colleagues and fellow collaborators (although that would require a subscription to Adobe’s Document Cloud). You can also add stamps, including Approved or Sign here.

You can add your signature to a document by typing, drawing with the mouse or trackpad, or adding an image.

Adobe Reader will also let you rotate pages.

If you need to convert to Word, RTF, Excel, or PowerPoint you would need to subscribe to the full version of Adobe Acrobat.

That said, we felt that we could do most of the things we wanted to (e.g. add attachments, search), but Adobe makes it look like you have to sign up for a subscription to get those features so we recommend digging a bit before you hand over your credit card details.

FineReader Pro for Mac

FineReader Pro for Mac

FineReader Pro for Mac
ABBYY
Get it here
Free trial (30 days or 100 pages)

This is the app to try if you want OCR (optical character recognition) capabilities. However, we nearly didn’t realise how deep the capabilities of this app went because the results can be a little hit-and-miss. Actually, the capabilities of the trial version of FineReader are pretty impressive, as long as you are willing to accept that it might not always do a great job of translating what it ‘sees’.

We discovered this when we imported our PDF and were greeted with a warning to “Please re-scan your document at a higher resolution”. Given the PDF we were imported hadn’t been scanned we were a little confused by this. Then when we exported the ‘scan’ to Word we saw a warning that some of the pages had not been recognised. The resulting Word document (actually we opened it in Pages) was a little muddled, some of the translations were laughable. But the general content had come through well enough for us to be able to correct the mistakes.

Now, this probably wouldn’t do for you if you wanted to edit a straightforward PDF - if that’s the case use one of the other apps. However, if you had scanned text from a book or a printout and you wanted to edit that then this is the app for you.

As we mentioned earlier, we had a scan we had taken with our iPhone camera via the Notes app and we were able to get FineReader to ‘read’ this and open it as a Word document, which we could then edit. Sure, there might be a few words that are wrong, but it’s got to be better than typing the whole thing out.

Once in Word (or Pages), you can edit the document as much as you like. We did see a warning that fonts were missing, and there was a strange case of paragraph formatting that caused the text to wrap to the next line as if it was in a box, but it was a good effort we thought.

As for collaboration and editing you have all the tools that are available in the app you end up opening the document in, be that Word, Pages, Excel, PowerPoint or something else.

It might not be spot on every time, but the fact that we were able to scan a document and export it to Word where we could edit it, was a real bonus.