If you are looking for a desktop Mac you have three choices: the iMac, the Mac mini and the Mac Pro. Desktop Macs, while not as portable as laptops, offer a lot of features that MacBooks lack, they are generally more powerful because they are able to use larger more power hungry components, and you will usually get much more for your money because you tend to pay a premium when it comes to laptops to reflect their more compact nature.
The Mac desktop that suits you depends on what your priorities are in terms of price and power. Here we will examine which desktop Mac offers you the best value for money - essentially the most powerful Mac desktop you can get without spending more than you need.
The cheapest Mac is the Mac mini (reviewed here). Prices start at just £479, that’s half the price of the MacBook Air, the next cheapest Mac, so it really is in a league of its own. It’s also the oldest Mac, so beware that what looks like a great deal might not be such a good deal when you consider what you could get if you paid a little more.
Another thing to consider with the Mac mini is the fact that you need to factor in the price of a screen, keyboard and mouse. Sure you might have all of those things already, but if you don't then you can expect to fork out at least £200 on top to the £479. When you consider that you could be paying more like £700 for the Mac mini, and one that is more than three years old at that, then it really doesn’t look like such an attractive option.
However, there are a few things that the Mac mini offers that you might consider worth the inconvenience of the lack of screen and the ageing specs.
Measuring just 19.7cm by 19.7cm squared, and 3.6cm high, it’s so small you’ll hardly notice it on your desk. It’s pretty light too, at 1.19kg, so if you needed to move it you could do so easily.
It’s so compact, you might like to pop it next to your TV use the TV as your screen. In fact the Mac mini is a popular choice as a media centre because it offers it offers some really useful ports if you wanted to use it this way, such as HDMI, so you can plug it straight into you TV, Gigabit Ethernet, so you can plug it in to the network and not be reliant on flakey WiFi when streaming content, it’s even got an IR receiver.
Several years ago Apple used to install Front Row software on Macs, which would have made the Mac mini an even better option for a media centre. It was a way of interacting with your music, movies, and photos in a simplified interface so that you didn’t have to be sitting directly in front of it with a keyboard and mouse.
You could use Apple’s infra-red remote control to play your the content while you sat on the sofa. Today if you want to use a Mac mini as a media server with your TV your best bet is something like Kodi, turns your Mac Mini into a fully-fledged set-top box able to play just about any type of music or video file stored on your Mac’s hard disk. Read about how to install Kodi on your Mac here: How to install Kodi v17 Krypton on a Mac.
That said, the Mac mini’s days are numbered as a media centre now that there are so many streaming options, including the Apple TV. People rarely own media, preferring to stream it from the likes of Netflix, if it's usefulness as a media centre was the only thing going for the Mac mini, it’s not really much of a selling point.
As for the attraction of the low price, we'd recommend looking at Apple’s refurbished store, or for a second hand option on eBay or similar, before forking out full price for a machine that hasn’t changed since 2014.
Another reason not to buy - Apple may be planning to update the Mac mini later in 2017, it’s certainly due an update and Apple has promised that the miniature Mac is still important to it, so we don’t think that it has assigned it to the dustbin yet.
Over the years the design has changed from the original CRT iMac in Bondi Blue, to today’s super slim, aluminium, flat screen stunner. If you want a beautiful computer sat on your desk this is the one (not surprisingly the iMac is a popular choice in office receptions).
Even better, not only is the iMac gorgeous, the range of iMacs is so wide and all encompassing that there is a iMac for everybody. You don’t have a sacrifice power and performance.
The iMac starting price is quite a lot higher than the Mac mini though. You can purchase the entry-level iMac for £1,049. This iMac features a 2.3GHz Intel Kaby Lake i5 processor, 1TB storage, 8GB RAM, and two Thunderbolt 3 ports. Unlike the other iMacs this entry level model doesn’t offer the high-resolution Retina display, but it does at least offer a display, unlike the Mac mini.
In comparison the entry-level Mac mini comes with a 1.4GHz Haswel processor, 4GB memory and a 500GB hard drive.
If you step up from that model to the mid-range Mac mini you can get a 2.6GHz Haswell processor, 8GB memory and 1TB storage, which is a little more comparable to the iMac, and now you can see just how bad a deal it is, because that Mac mini costs £679, lacks a monitor, and uses much older components. For £370 extra you’d get the monitor included and better specs.
Not that we are recommending that entry-level iMac though. For £200 more you can get a Retina 4K display, a 3GHz quad-core processor, and a discreet Radeon Pro graphics card, rather than an integrated card.
As for why you should choose an iMac as your Mac desktop. There are lots of reasons, here are a few:
The gorgeous Retina display, which is capable of showing 1 billion colours and has pixels so tightly packed together your eye can’t see them.
High performance graphics in the form of the Radeon Pro 500 series, making the iMac perfect for intensive graphic work as well as gaming.
Thunderbolt 3 which incorporates USB Type-C so you can take advantage of super fast data transfer to and from external drives and cameras (40 Gbps).
Another benefit is the fact that there are a lot of different iMacs to choose from. With two screen sizes (21.5-inch or 27-inch), and specs ranging from 2.3GHz to 4.2GHz, there really is something for everyone. We won’t go into too much detail here about the different models on offer, but we do have an article that answers the question: Which is the best iMac.
Before we move on to the final desktop Mac option, there is one more iMac to note. Apple says that it experienced so much interest from creative professionals in the iMac that it is creating a new iMac Pro just for them. This professional iMac will offer a workstation standard Xeon processors and high end graphics, and it will launch in late 2017. Read all about Apple's plans for the iMac Pro here.
In the meantime, if you are looking for a professional, workstation standard Mac, the only option is the Mac Pro. However, rather like the Mac mini, the Mac Pro is somewhat out of date.
Apple hasn’t updated the Mac Pro since it launched back in 2013, so as with the Mac mini we don’t recommend this model as a buy right now.
Like the Mac mini though, there are a few things that the Mac Pro has going for it. It has silent operation, so it’s been popular with audio professionals, and it’s design is certainly unique (and even more so given the likelihood that the new Mac Pro that Apple has promised for some point in the future (2018 possibly, but maybe 2019) will have an entirely new design.
The Mac Pro (reviewed here) price starts at almost £3k (£2,999) though so it really would be extravagant to buy one and we really wouldn’t recommend that you do so right now.
Right now we don't advise buying either the Mac mini or the Mac Pro, but that may well change in thr future if and when Apple updates those models.
For now, our advice is to buy an iMac if you want a Mac desktop. As for which iMac to buy, we recommend that you read this article: Which iMac 2017.