MacBook 2.26GHz 13in (late 2009) full review
In just three and a half years, the MacBook, targeted at average computer users, students, and PC switchers, has become Apple’s best-selling Mac model. In its first major remodeling since 2006, the white polycarbonate MacBook has gained many of the marquee features of the 13in MacBook Pro, including a unibody design, a glass trackpad, and an LED-backlit display.
In many ways, the white MacBook was the lone holdout among Apple portables. As the least-expensive model, it was missing several of the new design features that had already been made standard across the rest of the laptop line. One of the big ones was unibody construction. Making the MacBook’s main case out of a single piece of polycarbonate plastic (aluminum on all other Apple models) results in fewer parts, fewer screws, a lighter weight, and better durability. In switching to a unibody design, the new MacBook sheds the grayish surface that appeared grafted atop the frame in the previous model. The result is a consistent white colour, and a smoother surface without the sharp edges of the earlier generation. The keyboard also feels more solid and consistent.
Instead of nonskid pads in the corners on the bottom of the MacBook, the entire surface is one giant rubberized foot secured by eight Phillips screws. This surface is smoother and doesn’t provide as much friction as the pads on the older MacBooks did, and it collected a fair amount of dirt and debris from the desk (although a quick rub got it looking good as new).
Another problem with the unibody design is that it requires that the battery be built in. As with Apple’s other unibody laptops, the battery is not user-replaceable, but Apple says that the battery gives you between three and a half and seven hours of juice and up to 1,000 charge cycles before being reduced to 80 per cent capacity. Apple says that the battery should take about five years to reach that point, but your mileage will vary. The company charges £99 to replace the battery – the same price you'd pay for an extra battery for an older MacBook – which can be done as a same-day service in an Apple Store. It is still pretty easy, however, to access the hard drive and RAM slots for quick upgrades or replacements in those areas.
Integrating the battery into the design allows for a larger (and therefore longer-lasting) battery, plus it reduces some weight. In our battery test, the charge lasted for an impressive four hours and nine minutes while playing a looped video clip in QuickTime X at full screen and full brightness, but with AirPort turned off. That was exactly the same duration as the 13in 2.26GHz MacBook Pro, and 40 minutes longer than the previous MacBook. During that time (and during our other testing) the bottom of the MacBook never got very warm, which had been a complaint of some MacBook users in the past.
Also new is that the MacBook – like every other Mac laptop other than the Air – now has a glass Multi-Touch trackpad with gesture support. It's larger than the combined pad-and-button area on the old model. After using the new MacBook for a while, we found the smooth, large trackpad more enjoyable than the one on earlier-generation MacBooks. It takes some getting used to if you’ve been using the previous design, but the change is a good one.
The 13.3in display offers the same 1,280-by-800-pixel resolution as before, but as with all other Mac portables, the new MacBook uses LED backlighting on its display instead of CCFL (cold cathode fluorescent lamps). The display is noticeably brighter than before, and the switch to LED lets Apple finally add the MacBook to its list of arsenic- and mercury-free laptop displays. Viewed side by side with the screen of the older MacBook, the new MacBook’s screen shows a yellow colour shift when changing your horizontal viewing angle (the previous model simply got more washed out). The 13in MacBook Pro suffers from the same colour shifting.
The back of the screen has a slight taper that gives it a thinner appearance than that on MacBooks of yore, and a narrow rubber bezel protects the screen from coming into contact with the keyboard when you close the lid.
Overall, the new MacBook is slightly wider and deeper than its predecessor, although it shaves 0.3 pounds from the total weight. That small difference in weight is actually quite noticeable for someone like me, who’s been using the MacBook since it first came out. It is slightly larger in all dimensions than the 13in MacBook Pro, and weighs 2.13kg (90g more than its aluminum counterpart).
Ports and more
The new MacBook has a round iSight lens with only a status light to its right – the microphone has moved to the upper left corner of the keyboard area. The power button in the upper right corner of the keyboard area is smaller than before, which makes it a little harder to press.
On the front edge, the sleep status indicator is longer and narrower than before, but conspicuously absent is the infrared (IR) port that used to sit to the right of it. Without an IR port, you can’t use the new Apple Remote (or the older remote, for that matter) to control Front Row, volume, and the like. You can, however, use an iPhone or iPod touch with a remote app over Wi-Fi.
Speaking of ports, there are also some changes to the array of ports on the side of the MacBook. The biggest change is that there’s no longer a FireWire port on the MacBook – until now, it was a staple on all polycarbonate MacBooks. If you need a FireWire port – for connecting a camcorder or for using FireWire Target Disk Mode, for example – the MacBook isn’t for you. For £100 more, a 13in MacBook Pro with the same processor gives you a FireWire 800 port, plus an SD card slot, backlit keyboard, and an aluminum enclosure. However, that model includes only a 160GB hard drive versus the 250GB drive in the MacBook, should you wish to upgrade to a 250GB hard drive on the 13in MacBook Pro you’ll need to find £939 – and the extra £140 is a high price to pay for a Firewire port, SD card reader and backlit keyboard, and chances are, if you want the extra slots, you’d want the extra hard drive space too.
The display connection is now Mini DisplayPort (previously there was a mini-DVI connector), and Apple is using a single audio port for analog/digital output as well as line-in. The Sound preference pane has a Use Audio Port For pop-up menu, from which you can choose either Sound Output or Sound Input. The sound port also supports the Apple Stereo Headset with microphone. The other ports are gigabit ethernet, MagSafe power, two USB 2.0, and a Kensington lock slot. As before, the other side features an 8X slot-loading double-layer SuperDrive.
On the inside
The latest MacBook stills uses an Intel Core 2 Duo processor, but the speed of it has bumped from 2.13GHz to 2.26GHz. The new MacBook, like its predecessor, has 3MB of shared L2 cache. And although the MacBook maintains the same 1066MHz frontside bus as before, the new model supports 1066MHz DDR3 RAM as opposed to 800MHz DDR2 RAM.
The MacBook ships with 2GB, and Apple will double it to 4GB for an extra £80. Apple officially lists the maximum RAM at 4GB, but since it uses the same chipset and components as the 13in MacBook Pro, it does support up to 8GB as well. Of course, 4GB SO-DIMM RAM modules are still very expensive, but as prices drop in the next year or two, having that 8GB ceiling as an upgrade option will be a good thing. (Apple doesn't offer an 8GB option for the MacBook, and currently charges £560 to upgrade the MacBook Pro from 2GB to 8GB.)
With regard to graphics, the new MacBook uses the same Nvidia GeForce 9400M graphics processor, which shares 256MB of RAM with the main memory, as both the previous version and the 13in and low-end 15in MacBook Pros. In our Call of Duty test, the new MacBook produced almost one frame per second more than before, but a full frame per second less than the 13in MacBook Pro with the same specs.
Those who want extra screen space, or just the ability to use a matte screen rather than the glossy screen that ships with the MacBook, will be glad that the MacBook still lets you mirror or extend your desktop to a second display at up to 2,560 by 1,600 resolution at millions of colours. You won’t find any of the Mini DisplayPort adapters needed to connect to an external display, however, in the box. All are separate accessories from Apple. The MacBook also retains its 802.11n and Bluetooth 2.1 wireless networking.
Of course, if you want an antiglare display on your laptop, the only option open to you is the 15in or 17in MacBook Pro with the £34.78/£40 antiglare Widescreen Display option.
To gauge the new MacBook's speed, Macworld Lab ran our full suite of benchmarks. The new MacBook's slightly faster processor speed and improved RAM speed make this MacBook a little bit faster than its predecessor, as you might expect. Improvements ranged from 5.5 per cent faster for an iTunes MP3 encoding test to 17 per cent faster for an Aperture import test. The new MacBook shaved seven seconds off the Photoshop CS4 test suite (12.5 per cent), 13 seconds off our iMovie archive import test (10.4 per cent), and nine seconds off our unzip archive Finder test (11 per cent).
For those thinking that the extra £100 for the 2.26GHz 13in MacBook Pro might be a price worth paying, it’s worth noting that the new MacBook also matched or bested the 2.26GHz 13in MacBook Pro in almost all of our tests – somewhat surprising considering the two systems have almost identical components (although it’s possible that the MacBook Pro’s smaller hard drive was a factor). The MacBook blew the latest MacBook Air out of the water in all tests except our Finder folder duplication (only one second faster) and unzip archive (16 seconds slower) tests.