Apple MacBook Air (2018) vs Apple 12in MacBook (2017) full review
Apple's iPad Pro launch event on 30 Oct was gatecrashed by an old friend called the MacBook Air. Now that's a name I haven't heard in years, we all thought, before being pleasantly surprised by the comprehensive update this long-neglected laptop got for 2018.
In this article we take an in-depth look at the new MacBook Air for 2018, and compare it to Apple's other ultraportable laptop, the MacBook 12in (2017). We look at design, build quality, features, specs and value for money, and help you decide which is the machine for you.
For more general advice, see our MacBook buying guide.
Price & Availability
The MacBook 12in (2017) starts at £1,249/$1,299. The new MacBook Air is more expensive than its predecessor, the 2017 13in Air, but still slightly cheaper than the 12in model: it starts at £1,199/$1,199. Here's the full price list (although further build-to-order upgrades are available at additional cost):
- MacBook Air 13in (2018, 128GB): £1,199/$1,199
- MacBook Air 13in (2018, 256GB): £1,399/$1,399
- MacBook 12in (2017. 1.2GHz, 256GB): £1,249/$1,299
- MacBook 12in (2017, 1.3GHz, 512GB): £1,549/$1,599
Design & Build
There's little to choose between the devices in this department; whereas the original MacBook Air broke new ground in slimline ultraportability and the 12in MacBook took that design philosophy one step further, the new Air is more of the (beautiful, extremely portable) same.
Both devices are slim and taper to an even slimmer edge (hence the multiple dimensions for thickness):
- MacBook Air 13in (2018) dimensions: 304.1 x 212.4 x 4.1-15.6mm; 1.25kg
- MacBook 12in (2017) dimensions: 280.5 x 196.5 x 3.5-13.1mm; 0.92kg
The 12in is unsurprisingly the more portable of the two devices, but both will fit happily into a rucksack.
Both laptops are available in silver, gold (albeit a fairly pinkish gold) and Space Grey: they look effortlessly minimalist, although some will begrudge the reduction in port numbers (two on the Air, just one on the MacBook, and in each case one will be needed for power). And both have a mirrored, not glowing, Apple logo on the lid.
MacBook Air 13in (2018) in pictures
MacBook 12in (2017) in pictures
Specs & Features
Both laptops look great on the outside but a quick look at the specs list shows that the new Air is some way ahead on the interior.
If we compare entry-level models, which are priced closely together (the Air is £50/$100 cheaper), we find that the Air has a faster and newer processor (and a better integrated graphics setup), a higher-quality camera, a bigger battery (and two extra hours of estimated battery life), an extra USB-C port (and the ability for its ports to double as Thunderbolt), an extra microphone, a bigger screen and Touch ID.
It does have half as much storage at this lowest spec, though, which may be a downer for you; the cheapest Air has 128GB to the cheapest MacBook's 256GB. (The 256GB Air costs £1,399/$1,399, which leaves you £150/$100 in the hole compared to the 256GB MacBook, albeit still looking at lots of enhancements to justify the cost.)
Many users would regard 128GB as a manageable minimum, however, and you can store plenty of files in the cloud these days. Indeed, we tend to regard the Air's much wider range of storage capacities as a boon in itself: you can go anywhere from 128GB to 1.5TB, compared to 256GB or 512GB with the MacBook. It's easier to customise your Air to suit your precise storage requirements (and budget).
You can also read our predictions for the 2019 MacBook Air here.
MacBook Air 13in (2018) specs
- 1.6GHz dual-core Intel Core i5 processor (eighth generation)
- Intel UHD Graphics 617
- 8/16GB RAM
- 128/256/512GB/1.5TB SSD storage
- 13.3in (2560 x 1600 at 227ppi) 'Retina' LED screen, 16:10 aspect ratio
- FaceTime HD camera (720p)
- 50.3-watt-hour battery, claimed battery life 12 hours wireless web surfing, 30W USB-C power adapter
- Stereo speakers, 3 x microphones, 3.5mm headphone jack
- 2 x Thunderbolt 3/USB-C ports, Touch ID fingerprint scanner
- 802.11ac Wi‑Fi, Bluetooth 4.2
MacBook 12in (2017) specs
- 1.2GHz Intel Core m3, 1.3GHz Core i5 or 1.4GHz Core i7 processor (seventh generation)
- Intel HD Graphics 615
- 8/16GB RAM
- 256/512GB SSD storage
- 12in (2304 x 1440 at 226ppi) 'Retina' LED screen, 16:10 aspect ratio
- FaceTime camera (480p)
- 41.4-watt-hour battery, claimed battery life 10 hours wireless web surfing, 30W USB-C power adapter
- Stereo speakers, dual microphones, 3.5mm headphone jack
- 1 x USB-C port
- 802.11ac Wi‑Fi, Bluetooth 4.2
Both MacBooks run macOS, and if you buy either now it will come with macOS Mojave installed. Mojave is a popular update that adds a dark mode and far superior desktop organisation to the already attractive and user-friendly macOS experience.
Note that while all is equal for now, plumping for the older of these two machines may mean you stop getting free macOS updates slightly earlier, although Apple does not follow a predictable pattern.