MacBook Pro (17in, Mid 2009) review
Apple revamped nearly the entire Mac laptop line during the WWDC in June, leaving only the £749, entry level white MacBook untouched – although that model was revised just two weeks earlier. But while most models gained new capabilities, the 17in MacBook Pro was the sole Mac laptop that kept its design and feature set intact.
This isn’t surprising, considering it was just a few months earlier that Apple’s largest laptop joined its siblings in donning a unibody enclosure. Still, the company’s largest portable got improved performance and upgrade options while becoming more affordable.
What hasn’t changed
The latest version has the same basic features as the model that debuted at January’s Macworld Expo (and shipped in February). Along with its aluminium unibody enclosure and impressively long-life battery (more on that below), the laptop’s flagship feature is its 17in, mercury-free, LED-backlit display. Sporting a 1,920 x 1,200 pixel resolution, the screen is protected behind a thin sheet of arsenic-free glossy glass. The screen seems enormous, especially if you’re used to a 13in or 15in model, making it great for working with multiple windows or applications simultaneously.
On the other hand, the screen’s high resolution means that items on the screen are quite small; we often had to enlarge the size of onscreen type, especially when browsing the web. And while the screen produces exceptionally vivid colours and deep, dark blacks (this display uses the same 60 per cent-greater-colour-gamut technology Apple is touting on the smaller MacBook Pros) the frequent criticisms of glossy screens remain valid. If the laptop is positioned poorly, you end up with quite a bit of glare, and the large screen makes it that much more difficult to position the screen to avoid that glare. For the anti-glossy folks, Apple still offers a £40 build-to-order option for an anti-glare, matte screen.
The 17in MacBook Pro continues to feature dual video cards: the Nvidia GeForce 9600M GT with 512MB of dedicated memory, and the lesser-performing Nvidia GeForce 9400M, which shares 256MB of system memory. You can easily switch between them to get better performance or battery life, respectively, although switching requires you to log out and then log back in. You still get a 1,066MHz front side bus, 4GB of 1,066MHz DDR3 memory (upgradeable to 8GB), an 8x slot-loading SuperDrive, Gigabit Ethernet, three USB 2.0 ports, a single FireWire 800 port, AirPort Extreme WiFi (supporting 802.11n draft and 802.11a/b/g), Bluetooth 2.1 + EDR (Enhanced Data Rate), an iSight camera, a backlit keyboard, and separate audio input and output jacks (each of which auto-switches between optical-digital and analog). The MacBook Pro also includes built-in stereo speakers, a mono microphone, Apple’s MagSafe power jack, and a Kensington lock slot. All ports are located on the left-hand side of the laptop, with the optical drive slot on the right.
As with all current MacBook Pro models, the 17in model features Apple’s large, multi-touch trackpad. The trackpad makes multi-touch gestures easy-and fun-to use, although it requires an adjustment period for people used to a traditional trackpad with separate buttons. The physical click, which requires you to depress the entire trackpad, feels especially odd. Even after using a recent 13in MacBook with a similar trackpad for several months, we prefer the touch-sensitive-tap approach, which you can enable in Trackpad preferences.
The MacBook Pro’s Mini DisplayPort jack supports VGA, DVI, and dual-link DVI video output using the appropriate adaptor. Unfortunately, no video adaptors are included, not even the basic DVI version, which will cost you another £20. Similarly, you can use an Apple Remote with the 17in MacBook Pro, but you have to pay another £15 to get it. These omissions feel cheap given the price you’re paying for the computer.
The 17in model retains the same dimensions as its short-lived predecessor: 15.5in wide, 10.5in deep, just under 1in thick, and weighing 2.99kg. And unlike its 15in siblings, which now feature an SD-memory-card slot, the latest 17in MacBook Pro keeps the popular-with-pros ExpressCard/34 slot, making it the only Mac laptop with such expandability.
Speedmark Scores for the 17 inch MacBook Pro range
Improvements in value
So what did Apple change since February’s model? Not much, but those changes serve to make the 17in MacBook Pro a better value proposition. First, the stock processor is now a 2.8GHz Core 2 Duo, up slightly from the previous model’s 2.66GHz. (Level 2 cache remains at 6MB.) Second, you get more storage in the form of a 500GB 5,400rpm hard drive, up from 320GB. And that’s it on the hardware side. But while these are relatively minor changes, Apple also lowered the price of the laptop from £1,949 to £1,849. It’s tough to argue with better value.
Apple also improved the build-to-order upgrade options for the largest MacBook Pro. You can now bump the processor up to 3.06GHz for £240; the previous CPU upgrade, priced similarly, topped out at 2.93GHz. An upgrade to a 7,200rpm drive with the same 500GB capacity is now £40 (slightly more, it was previously £34.99). But the cost of upgrading to a solid-state drive (SSD) is now lower: a 128GB model will set you back £160 (compared to £240 previously), and a 256GB model costs £520 (compared to £600 before).
As you might expect (and saw earlier in our benchmarks analysis of all the new MacBook Pros), given the minor bump in processor speed, the latest 17in MacBook Pro doesn’t exactly leave its predecessor in the dust. In fact, for most tasks in Macworld’s benchmarking suite, the differences between 2.66GHz and 2.8GHz are barely noticeable – a few seconds here and there. The result is a Speedmark improvement of only 3 per cent, from 249 to 256, compared to the February model.
But that’s not necessarily a bad thing. In day-to-day use, the 17in MacBook Pro, like the latest top-of-the-line 15in 2.8GHz MacBook Pro, offers impressive performance for a laptop. In fact, with the exception of hard-drive-intensive tasks, which are slowed by the 5,400rpm laptop hard drive, moving from a Mac Pro to this MacBook Pro didn’t result in a noticeable drop in performance. That says a lot about the performance of Apple’s current notebooks.
Similarly, the battery life of the latest model is essentially unchanged from its predecessor’s. But, again, that’s not a complaint. The 17in MacBook Pro’s battery life increased dramatically when Apple integrated its latest (non-removable) battery technology in the February model. That model clocked in at 4 hours 20 minutes in our standard test, which involves looping a full-screen video file with the display at full brightness, Energy Saver settings set to never sleep, and using the lower-powered GeForce 9400M graphics. The latest model lasted almost exactly as long: 4 hours 18 minutes.
We also tested the MacBook Pro under lighter use, similar to that of Apple’s official battery testing: surfing the web over a wireless connection and using office applications, such as Microsoft Excel and Word, with the display set to half brightness. (During this test, there were occasional periods where the laptop wasn’t actively being used; however, the computer and screen never went to sleep.) Under those conditions, the 17in MacBook Pro ran continuously for a jaw-dropping 8 hours 20 minutes, which should be long enough for many people to overlook the fact that they can’t swap the battery in the field for a fresh one. And because of the technology in this battery, Apple says it should last for around 1,000 charges, enough for about five years of typical use.
The latest 17in MacBook Pro is by all measures a minor hardware upgrade over its predecessor, offering only slightly faster processor options and a bump in hard-drive capacity. The more significant change is the value you get for your money: Apple has dropped the price of the computer by £100 and similarly reduced the price of build-to-order upgrades. If you purchased a 17in MacBook Pro after February’s unibody introduction, there’s little reason to upgrade now – or to regret your earlier purchase. But if you’ve been on the fence about splurging for the monster of all MacBooks, the decision to buy just got easier: this is the fastest Mac laptop ever, at the lowest price Apple has ever charged for a top-of-the-line notebook. This lower price also makes the 17in model more appealing to those considering the 15in MacBook Pro but who need an ExpressCard slot or who prefer a matte screen, as this is, sadly, the only Mac laptop still offering those features. And while moving up to the 17in model means lugging around a considerably larger machine, you also get incredible battery life and a screen big enough for this to truly be a desktop replacement.
Benchmarks for the MacBook Pro range